Supermarket
Strike
The Parties
After
the expiration of the predecessor agreement on October 5th, employees
at Vons and Pavilions (Safeway) went out on strike on October 11th.
Albertsons and Ralphs (Krogers) then locked out their employees
who are represented by seven (7) locals of the United Food &
Commercial Workers (UFCW). The companies and the UFCW agreed in
August that a strike against one would be a strike against the others
and the companies retained the right to lock out their employees.
Number
of Employees & Stores Affected
More
than 70,000 employees, in more than 852 stores in Southern California
have been affected. Employees turned out in unprecedented numbers
(over 80%) and voted overwhelmingly (over 95%) to authorize a strike
against the stores. The last strike in 1978 against Ralphs and Vons
lasted four (4) days.
Unemployment
Compensation & Health & Pension Contributions
None
of the striking or locked out employees have received unemployment
insurance as the State denied coverage. The companies stopped making
contributions to their health and pension plans the day the strike
began.
Companies'
Position
The
companies are insisting that current employees start to contribute
towards the cost of their health care. Currently, employees make
no contribution for their medical, prescription drug, dental or
vision plans. The companies have proposed a weekly contribution
of $5 for the employee and $15 for a family.
The companies are
also proposing to increase over three (3) years their contributions
to the health plans by more than the 40% and their pension contributions
by 57%.
New Employees
New
employees, however would be required to pay more for their medical
coverage as the companies are proposing to cut and cap their hourly
contributions. In addition, the top hourly rate for a newly hired
clerk would be reduced from $17.95 to $15.10. The progression to
the top rate would take five (5) years instead of two (2) years
for current employees. There also would be reduction in the pension
benefit.
Union's
Objections
CFCW
is concerned about this two (2) tier wage and benefit structure
for several reasons. First, as new hires replace the current workforce,
the existing jobs would over time come without any meaningful benefits
and the average salary for a full time Clerk would decline by more
than $6,000 per year. Secondly, current employees would be required
to pay much more for their health insurance since the company contributions
that have been reduced for new hires would also be segregated from
the insurance pool for existing employees.
The union states
that ultimately the cost of insurance for existing employees would
increase to $95 per week. The companies deny this.
Wage Increases
The
companies have proposed two (2) bonus payments over the term of
a three (3) year prospective agreement. One of the bonus payments
would be payable as of the date the new agreement is ratified.
Competition
The
companies respond that Wal-Mart, their principal competitor is planning
to open more than 40 super centers in Southern California over the
next several years. Wal-Mart pays its employees who are not organized,
less money. In addition, other competitors, such as gas station
marts and ethnic markets to name just a few are also taking away
market share.
Labor Costs
as a Percent of Sales
In
the Los Ageless Times on Sunday, February 15, James Flanigan reported
that while Costco pays very competitive wages and benefits, its
labor costs amount to only 7% of annual sales. On the other hand,
Wal-Mart and the super market chains, which pay less than Costco,
have labor costs as a percent of sales of 12% and 16%, respectively.
This is so because both Wal-Mart & the supermarket chains are
less productive and have higher turnover rates.
Losses
Safeway
has reported it is losing $2 million per day from the strike while
a full time employee is losing more than $4,600 in wages and benefits
every 35 days.
Binding
Arbitration
In
an effort to end the strike UFCW offered binding arbitration that
the companies rejected. The companies are insisting that the parties
are best equipped to resolve the dispute without the intervention
of an outsider who would impose a settlement.
Federal
Mediation & Conciliation Services
The
parties are meeting under the auspices of Peter Hurtgen, Director
of the Federal Mediation & Conciliation Services (FMCS).
Stay Informed
If
you would like additional information, you can access Ralphs' web
site at www.kremployeeinfo.com/socal,
or their hot line (800) 615-7279. The union's hot line number is
(213) 487-7070, ext. 106. |